• Latest
  • Trending
Mahikeng protesters to appear in court

Parliament and Cabinet dragged to court for not enacting Covid-19 law

September 3, 2020
President John Magufuli died from coronavirus, says Tanzania opposition leader

President John Magufuli died from coronavirus, says Tanzania opposition leader

March 18, 2021
Four dead, 16 injured in Eastern Cape crash

Police officers arrested for the killing of Mthokozisi Ntumba to appear in court

March 17, 2021
Armed men attack passenger convoy and village in Niger, killing 58

Armed men attack passenger convoy and village in Niger, killing 58

March 17, 2021
Ramaphosa vist EFF’s Seshego stronghold, says corrupt people will be jailed

CR17 bank statements never entered into court records: Lawyer

March 17, 2021
City of CT ‘managing’ load shedding as power cuts hit SA again

Eskom says possible heavy load shedding this winter if capacity is not met

March 16, 2021
EFF Student Command at UP calls for postponement of 2021 academic year

EFF Student Command at UP calls for postponement of 2021 academic year

March 16, 2021
Pick n Pay agrees to cap ginger and garlic pricing

Pick n Pay agrees to cap ginger and garlic pricing

March 15, 2021
TUT students won’t be joining nationwide fees protest, for now

TUT students won’t be joining nationwide fees protest, for now

March 15, 2021
Survivors of Equatorial Guinea blasts recall trauma

Survivors of Equatorial Guinea blasts recall trauma

March 15, 2021
Hundreds of drunk drivers arrested in Gauteng

JMPD deploys officers in Joburg CBD ahead of student protests

March 15, 2021
Students can apply for payment plans to cover registration fee: UWC

Nationwide university shutdown

March 15, 2021
ANCWL in the North West backs embattled Mahumapelo

Mahumapelo calls for removal of Dodovu

March 15, 2021
  • Latest
    • Community
    • Africa
    • International
  • Sport
  • Business
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Motoring
  • People
    • Opinions
    • Health
  • Politics
  • Media
    • Entertaiment
    • Social Media
    • Media
  • Public Statement
Thursday, April 15, 2021
  • Login
TP
  • Latest
    • Community
    • Africa
    • International
  • Sport
  • Business
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Motoring
  • People
    • Opinions
    • Health
  • Politics
  • Media
    • Entertaiment
    • Social Media
    • Media
  • Public Statement
No Result
View All Result
  • Latest
    • Community
    • Africa
    • International
  • Sport
  • Business
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Motoring
  • People
    • Opinions
    • Health
  • Politics
  • Media
    • Entertaiment
    • Social Media
    • Media
  • Public Statement
No Result
View All Result
TownPress
No Result
View All Result
Home Community

Parliament and Cabinet dragged to court for not enacting Covid-19 law

September 3, 2020
in Community, Politics
0
Mahikeng protesters to appear in court
161
SHARES
798
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Cape Town – The Gauteng High Court, Pretoria, will hear an urgent application on Thursday by the Helen Suzman Foundation (HSF) which wants Parliament and the Cabinet ordered to pass Covid-19 legislation.

National Assembly Speaker Thandi Modise, President Cyril Ramaphosa, the Cabinet, Cogta Minister Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma, and National Council of Provinces chairperson Amos Masondo are cited as respondents in their official capacity.

Modise is opposing the application.

It could not be immediately established if Ramaphosa and others were opposing the application.

The application follows a failed bid by the foundation when it filed papers in the Constitutional Court on May 21 seeking direct access. The court ruled on July 3 that it did not fall within its jurisdiction.

The foundation subsequently lodged a new application in the high court on August 25 seeking the same relief.

In his founding affidavit, the foundation’s director, Francis Antonie, said the foundation had lodged the application because Parliament and the Cabinet had failed to pass the law on Covid-19.

Antonie said they had also failed to fulfill their constitutional responsibilities to respect and promote the rights in the Bill of Rights.

“This application is not about the merits or otherwise of any regulations, directions, or other substantive exercises of power by the minister of Cogta, the president or Cabinet relating to Covid-19.

“The Covid-19 crisis has required difficult decisions and urgent responses about which reasonable people might disagree,” he said, acknowledging the enormous burden that has fallen on the shoulders of Ramaphosa and the government.

Antonie also said the application was solely concerned with a narrow question to do with the structure and location of power under the Constitution.

“It is now critical that the proper location of that power be restored, not only in the present crisis but for the long-term importance of our constitutional object.”

Antonie maintained that the Cabinet and Parliament had failed in their constitutional duties to exercise the legislative and executive authority to deal with Covid-19.

He said both had failed to introduce and pass legislation on Covid-19, and that the Cogta minister was permitted, alone or with others, to exercise sweeping powers under the Disaster Management Act (DMA) to limit and direct how persons, both natural and juristic, live or act, in almost every aspect of their daily existence.

Antonie charged that the DMA could operate for a very short time until Parliament and the Cabinet reclaimed their legislative and executive roles.

“It is evident that Parliament and the national executive believe that the minister can exercise her power for as long as Covid-19 presents a threat. This could be for months or even years, meaning that the state’s response to Covid-19 will remain exclusively within the subjective purview of the executive branch of government.”

Antonie also said the court should declare the failures of the Cabinet and Parliament unconstitutional, and order them to exercise their duties to deal adequately with the threat of Covid-19.

The Cabinet and Parliament should be directed to enact legislation on Covid-19 without delay, he added.

Modise, in her answering affidavit, said the relief sought was mistaken as a matter of fact and law.

She said the Disaster Management Act was promulgated by Parliament to provide for the government’s response to a national disaster, and Covid-19 was one.

Modise also said there was no mandatory obligation on Parliament to pass the legislation as sought by the foundation.

“The applicant has failed to point out any specific provision of the Constitution which requires the respondents to initiate and pass such legislation.”

She also maintained that the order, if granted, would be ineffective.

“Even if the court found that Parliament has failed to act in accordance with its constitutional obligation, the order the applicant seeks is impermissible because it is unenforceable,” Modise said.

The National Assembly Speaker said Parliament had exercised oversight over the Cabinet and Cogta’s responses to Covid-19.

Modise also said the Helen Suzman Foundation had not provided credible evidence to suggest the oversight was constitutionally insufficient.

She asked the court to dismiss the “ill-founded” application with costs.

“The judicial intervention the application prays for is inappropriate and unwarranted in the circumstances,” Modise said.

Comments

Share65Tweet40Share11Share16Send
Previous Post

MEC Maile revealved that Tshwane finances stay afloat despite Covid-19 challenges

Next Post

Nehawu to embark on total shutdown if demands are not met

Next Post
Nehawu to embark on total shutdown if demands are not met

Nehawu to embark on total shutdown if demands are not met

Please login to join discussion
No Result
View All Result
Currently Playing

SAElections2019 Indelible Ink & Election Fraud

SAElections2019 Indelible Ink & Election Fraud

00:01:40

Why would Mampintsha assault Babes Wodumo?

00:00:40

Alph Lukau “raising the dead” is a fraud

00:01:36

Moozlie Mabena involved in a live video crash

00:00:58

Welkom Hijack Man shot in parking lot

00:01:04

Female theft suspects tries to evade guards at Clear Water Mall

00:01:48

Franchise Driver on duty with sex worker

00:00:47

Courageous female driver attack hjackers on driveway

00:01:33

University of Zululand Student stabbed to death by roommate

00:00:41

Vehicle High Jacking on Cedar road, Midrand

00:01:57

Watch thief steal a Hilux in Bloemfontein

00:01:05

Watch Mosque Shoe snatchers in action

00:00:43

Watch these Unbelievable Shoplifters Caught with the Loot

00:03:13

Journalist attacked by EFF Floyd Shivambu and security details

00:00:43

Attempted cash in transit heist by DSTV office in Randburg

00:00:48

KFM Presenters and the Three Rs Blunder

00:00:59

SAPS Higspeed chase

00:01:08

Ruthless home invaders in westrand

00:01:30

Dj Khomza bashes girlfriend with a spanner

00:01:56

Daybreak Robbery in Auckland Park

00:01:15

Fake Police arrested in Johannesburg

00:01:00

#MduduziManana assault video at Cubana

00:00:29

Racial assault of couple at KFC montana

00:01:22

Smart Porsche driver escapes hijackers in Johannesburg

00:00:49

VW Polo Hijack at Kempton Park filling station

00:02:13

Women caught husband cheating and jumps on Carhood

00:02:02

Carlton Centre, Joburg Heist

00:01:06

Did Malema call Mandela a Sellout ?

00:02:01

Petrol Attendant beat up a man

00:01:01

Car Hijack gone wrong

00:02:15

Armed robbery in Alberton

00:00:52

Mother and son in Polokwane attacked by panga wielding robbers

00:02:04

Hyundai i10 Hijacking in Chatsworth

00:00:59

Check more Videos on Youtube

Connect

Connect
TownPress

Copyright © 2021 Townpress.

Navigate Site

  • Terms and conditions
  • About Us
  • Subscription
  • Contact
  • Account

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Latest
    • Community
    • Africa
    • International
  • Sport
  • Business
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Motoring
  • People
    • Opinions
    • Health
  • Politics
  • Media
    • Entertaiment
    • Social Media
    • Media
  • Public Statement

Copyright © 2021 Townpress.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Go to mobile version
This site uses cookies to improve user experience: Find out more.